As the 7 May local elections loom with the prospect of catastrophic losses for the governing Labour Party, whispers of a leadership challenge against Sir Keir Starmer have grown into something approaching an open conversation in Westminster. The question is no longer if Labour’s electoral humiliation will prompt a leadership contest, but when — and who will be first to move against the Prime Minister.
The Scale of What’s Coming
Even by the bleak standards that Labour insiders have been preparing themselves for, the projected results for Thursday’s local elections are alarming. Internal polling and canvass returns reportedly align with public surveys showing the party on course to lose well over a thousand council seats. Labour is defending ground won during the 2022 local elections when it polled around 35%. It now sits below 21% nationally.
The losses are expected to be concentrated in the metropolitan boroughs of the north and Midlands — areas that formed the bedrock of Labour’s 2024 general election victory. If those communities are turning away from Labour at this scale within two years of a landslide win, the party faces existential questions about its electoral coalition.
Wes Streeting: The Frontrunner Who Doesn’t Want to Go First
Health Secretary Wes Streeting has emerged as the most-discussed potential challenger to Starmer’s leadership. Reports suggest he has secured the backing of more than 81 Labour MPs — a figure that meets the threshold required to formally trigger a leadership contest under party rules. That is a remarkable level of declared support for someone who has not yet announced any intention to stand.
Yet Streeting remains cautious. Political history suggests that the person who plunges the knife rarely inherits the throne, and Streeting is understood to be wary of being seen as an opportunist who destabilised the government during a difficult period. His allies are watching the post-election landscape carefully, looking for the right moment to move — one where the case for change appears overwhelming rather than self-serving.
Andy Burnham: The People’s Choice Who Isn’t Ready
Among the Labour membership, few figures command greater popularity than Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham. His record on housing, transport and public health in the north of England has made him a respected voice in progressive politics, and polling consistently shows him as the preferred choice of Labour members for a future leadership.
The fundamental problem is that Burnham is not a Member of Parliament. To stand for the Labour leadership, he would need to win a Westminster seat, which means a byelection — a process that takes weeks and requires a sitting MP in a safe seat to stand aside. Burnham’s supporters are reportedly working to identify such a seat, and several sympathetic MPs have already indicated a willingness to make way for him.
The question is timing. If a contest moves quickly after the local elections, Burnham may not be able to get himself into position in time. His supporters are therefore calling for any leadership race to be delayed until he can properly contest it.
Angela Rayner: A Dark Horse in the Race
Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner should not be discounted. She has a passionate base of support in the trade union movement and among the party’s grassroots, and her profile has remained high throughout the parliament. Polling has consistently suggested she would be a formidable candidate if she chose to stand, though she has given little public indication of her intentions.
A Rayner candidacy would likely represent a more left-leaning alternative to Streeting, potentially reshaping the ideological terms of the contest and making it less straightforwardly a choice between centrist continuity and centrist change.
Starmer’s Position
Starmer himself has given no public indication that he intends to resign, and his allies insist he remains committed to leading Labour into the next general election. The Prime Minister’s supporters argue that changing leader now, with several years of parliament still to run, would be destabilising and ultimately counter-productive.
However, political history offers little comfort for leaders who suffer catastrophic local election results. The momentum in Westminster is clearly shifting, and unless the actual results on Thursday exceed the grim projections, the pressure on Starmer is unlikely to ease after the votes are counted.
What Happens After Thursday
The coming days will be pivotal. If the results match or exceed the worst predictions, expect a rapid intensification of calls for change. How Starmer responds in his immediate post-election statement — whether he acknowledges the scale of the verdict and signals a willingness to change course, or tries to minimise the damage — could determine whether the party rallies behind him or tips over into open revolt. Either way, British politics is entering a period of considerable turbulence.
