A serving Thames Valley Police officer is due to appear in court at the end of this month charged with causing the death of a young woman in Aylesbury five years ago. The case has been referred to by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC), which completed a reinvestigation last December and passed the file to the Crown Prosecution Service, which then authorised the charge.
The Incident in April 2021
The incident that led to this charge happened on April 16, 2021, on the A41 in Aylesbury. PC Duthie, a Thames Valley Police officer then aged 36, was responding to a report of a serious incident elsewhere in the town. While driving to the scene, his vehicle struck Kimberley Cameron, a 27-year-old woman who was crossing the road. Ms Cameron died at the scene.
The collision was subject to an initial investigation, and then — following a complaint — a reinvestigation by the IOPC that ran through to December 2025. The process took longer than many families would consider acceptable, but the IOPC has stated that the complexity of the case and the need to ensure a thorough review of all evidence necessitated the extended timeline.
The Charge
PC Duthie, now 41, has been charged with one count of causing death by careless driving contrary to section 2B of the Road Traffic Act 1988. He is due to appear at Westminster Magistrates’ Court on April 27, 2026.
The CPS applied the standard test in deciding whether to charge: is there sufficient evidence for a realistic prospect of conviction, and is it in the public interest to proceed? In this case, the CPS concluded that both conditions were met.
Careless driving is defined in law as driving that falls below the standard expected of a competent and careful driver. The fact that Officer Duthie was responding to an emergency call at the time of the collision will be a relevant factor in any proceedings, but it does not automatically exempt an officer from liability for the manner in which they drive.
Thames Valley Police’s Position
Thames Valley Police has confirmed that PC Duthie is still a serving officer but has not commented on the specifics of the case, citing the ongoing legal proceedings. The force has expressed condolences to the family of Kimberley Cameron on multiple occasions since the incident and has said it fully cooperated with the IOPC’s reinvestigation.
The case will now proceed through the criminal justice system. Given the charge is being heard initially at a Magistrates’ Court, it may be committed up to Crown Court depending on how proceedings develop. Cases of this nature are treated as criminal matters, separate from any internal disciplinary proceedings the force may also be pursuing.
The Broader Context: Police Driving Cases
Cases involving police officers who cause deaths while on duty represent a small but significant category of criminal prosecutions in England and Wales. Officers driving on blue lights are trained to drive at higher speeds and through red lights when appropriate, but they are expected to do so in a way that does not create unacceptable danger to other road users.
The law recognises the difficult circumstances police face in emergency situations. A responding officer who drives carefully but makes an error of judgement is in a different position from one who drives with obvious recklessness. The courts consider all of these factors in assessing liability, and acquittals in this area of law are not unusual.
But for families like that of Kimberley Cameron, the charge represents a moment of recognition — an acknowledgement that the death of their loved one is being treated as a serious matter requiring accountability. Whether that accountability ultimately results in a conviction will be decided by the court.
The April 27 Hearing
PC Duthie’s appearance at Westminster Magistrates’ Court on April 27 is expected to be a preliminary hearing at which the charge is put and an initial plea is entered. The substantive trial, if there is one, would likely take place later in the year. Anyone seeking to follow the case can check the publicly available court listing for the Westminster Magistrates’ Court.
Kimberley Cameron’s family has asked for privacy during what will be a difficult month as the case moves into the public domain. She was 27 years old at the time of her death, and those who knew her have described her in terms that paint a picture of a young woman whose life was cut short in circumstances that her family have spent five years seeking answers about.
